Choosing the best toaster oven for your individual needs can be challenging. Aside from needing an appliance that is multifunctional, you must also consider the fact that it will sit on your countertop and, therefore, style means a lot too.
In addition to this, you need to keep your budget in mind as modern toaster ovens can range from anywhere between $40 and $200 or more.
In order to choose the best toaster oven for your kitchen, you must think about the key reasons why you are buying one in the first place. For example, do you want to save time while cooking? Or, are you looking to save some space in your kitchen?
Whatever the reason, we’ve created this buying guide to make your task easier. We’ll start by telling you about some of the best toaster ovens on the market today based on their price range.
We’ll then share some of the top reasons you should pay attention when choosing the best toaster oven for your individual needs. Lastly, we’ll highlight some of the key features you should consider in order for you to purchase a product that meets yours and your family’s expectations.
So, without further ado, let’s get started.
Best Toaster Oven Over $100
Best Toaster Oven Under $100
Our recommendations for the best toaster oven over $100:
If you’ve got a hefty budget for your appliance and want to buy the best toaster oven your money can get you, we recommend you check out the Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven 1800-Watt Convection Toaster Oven with Element IQ.
Packed with a mound of features, this Breville model was designed with consumers in mind. Offering 1800W with 5 Quarts heating elements, this toaster oven allows you to cook virtually any meal quickly and easily.
Not only this, the Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven 1800-Watt Convection Toaster Oven comes with Element IQ cooking technology, allowing it to control the power of the 5 quarts for evenly cooked food.
This Breville toaster oven comes with nine different preset cooking options which include toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, and warm, allowing you to choose the best settings for your ingredients.
In addition to all the above, this Breville model comes with convection heating technology. This means that if you choose to bake in this toaster oven, the convection heater uses a fan to distribute heat evenly around your food, thus leaving you with perfectly cooked ingredients.
All the setting mentioned above are designed as guidelines to make the cooking process that little bit easier, but they can also be altered according to the recipe you have chosen to cook.
The customized settings you use will be saved into the product’s memory so that you don’t have to use guesswork next time you cook your favorite dishes. These are saved until manually changed or until the unit is unplugged from its power source.
The Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven 1800-Watt Convection Toaster Oven with Element IQ is built with the most durable materials. It comes reinforced in a stainless steel housing and the elements are made of Quarts rather than cheaper metals found in other models.
In addition to all the above, it comes with a non-stick interior with three rack positions, a tempered glass door, a magnetic auto-reject rack, a pull-out crumb tray, and a backlit, easy-to-read LCD screen that changes color according to the cooking cycle.
Last but not least, this Breville model is very reasonably priced at less than $205 per unit and can be bought from Amazon with an additional 3 or 4 years of protection for just over $15 and just under $34 respectively.
If the above product is slightly above your price range and doesn’t quite meet your individual needs, we recommend you check out the Cuisinart TOB-195 Exact Heat Toaster Oven Broiler.
Aside from being extremely stylish thanks to its stainless steel finish, this Cuisinart model is packed with features that will make your cooking experience that little bit more straightforward.
Thanks to its 0.6-cubic-foot capacity this toaster oven can toast up to 6 slices of sliced bread at any one time, allowing you to feed your entire household every morning.
Not only this, you’ll benefit from eight different functionalities, enabling you to cook a huge variety of meals. These settings include pizza, bake, broil, toast, convection, bagel, reheat, and defrost.
All aforementioned functions can be set because of the electronic touchpad controls the Cuisinart TOB-195 Exact Heat Toaster Oven Broiler comes with. Plus, it also has a clock and an oven timer so you can be sure to never burn your food.
In addition to all the above, this Cuisinart toaster oven comes with an easy-to-clean interior. All you have to do is wipe it down with a damp cloth after every use and it’ll be ready to cook its next meal.
Customers who reviewed this product say that they now use it more than their regular oven and have even bought additional models for friends and family members.
Not only this, the Cuisinart TOB-195 Exact Heat Toaster Oven Broiler has been reported as easy to use, so much so that many didn’t read the manual before getting started and have not encountered any problems as of yet.
Aside from the fact that this toaster oven heats up in a matter of minutes, it is also the perfect size for virtually any kitchen. It has been described as unobtrusive while also being big enough to cook a 12-inch pizza.
Last but not least, while it does not quite have the functionalities that the Breville model mentioned above has, it does have a significantly lower price tag of just under $180.
Plus, if you make your purchase from Amazon, you’ll benefit from free shipping straight to your doorstep. And, if you want a little more security, you can purchase an additional 3 or 4 years of protection for just over $10 and just over $27 respectively.
Let's take a look on the best toaster ovens under $100 on the market:
If spending more than $100 on a toaster oven is unrealistic for you, we recommend you check out the Oster Large Capacity Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven.
Offering enough space to prepare food for the entire family, this Oster model comes with a large interior capacity allowing you to cook everything from a thin pizza to a juicy roast. Plus, you’ll benefit from two different rack positions so that your food cooks evenly.
This Oster model features convection baking which circulates hot air around the entire oven thus allowing you to cook a larger variety of foods. This is also a great way to brown and crisp foods more quickly and to ensure your food is cooked evenly.
The control panel is not only user-friendly, but also completely digital thus offering precise heat and time adjustments as well as multiple preset functions such as bake, convection, toast, pizza, defrost, warm, and broil.
Thanks to its 90-minute countdown function, this toaster oven will turn itself off according to your individual cooking preferences.
Not only this, this toaster oven allows you to choose your shade of toast meaning that you can choose whether you’d like your bread and pastries lightly or darkly toasted.
The Oster Large Capacity Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven comes with an adjustable broil setting making it perfect for when you want to crisp or melt the top of a pasta bake, for example.
Designed in a stainless steel finish, this Oster model is slick, stylish, and the perfect addition to any kitchen. It comes with a large interior light enabling you to better gauge your meal’s progress and is extremely easy to wipe clean after every use.
Not only this, the Oster Large Capacity Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven comes with a removable crumb tray making the cleaning process that little bit easier. Plus, a durable baking pan also comes included.
Made with performance, versatility, and durability in mind, this Oster toaster oven is our favorite model for less than $100. It is the best toaster oven for cooking everything from pizzas to casseroles and comes with a mound of functions not seen anywhere else for this low price.
By purchasing it on Amazon, you’ll benefit from the low price of just over $62 and you’ll have the opportunity to buy an additional 3 or 4 years of protection for less than $5 and $9 respectively.
If the above model doesn’t quite tickle your fancy, we recommend you check out the BLACK+DECKER Countertop Convection Toaster Oven. Offering cooking versatility at the touch of just a few buttons, this Black and Decker model is among the most powerful of its kind.
The convection feature on this model means that heat is distributed evenly and quickly throughout the entire oven, thus allowing it to cook all your meals through. Plus, thanks to its extra-deep interior, you’ll be able to cook anything from a 12-inch pizza to a casserole.
The BLACK+DECKER Countertop Convection Toaster Oven comes with a dual position rack so you can place your meals exactly where you need them to be. Whether you want to crisp the top of a pasta bake or roast a chicken, the opportunities are endless with this model.
One of its most prominent features is the fact that it comes with a 120-minute timer which offers accurate results because it turns itself off once the time on the timer has elapsed.
This Black and Decker model comes with 8 functions, these include bake, broil, toast, bagel, pizza, frozen snacks, potatoes, and cookies. Best of all, it comes with an awesome non-stick interior making it quick and easy to clean after every use.
Thanks to its large glass door, you can keep an eye on your food during the cooking process and its removable crumb tray means you can avoid burnt crumbs in the bottom of your oven. Not only this, it comes with a bake pan which fits perfectly in the oven for better cooking results.
Last but not least, you can choose the BLACK+DECKER Countertop Convection Toaster Oven with either a dual rack position or three rack position, both of which come with different measurements and, of course, price tags.
The dual rack model is very reasonably priced at just under $55 per unit, including free shipping straight to your doorstep if you have an Amazon Prime membership.
Not only this, by purchasing it from Amazon, you’ll be able to check out the nearly 2,000 reviews left by customers who bought this product, the large majority of which were extremely happy with their buying decision.
If you’re looking for something a little different to the two aforementioned products, we recommend you check out the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Oven with Convection.
While small enough to fit on virtually any kitchen counter, this Hamilton Beach model allows you to cook anything from six pieces of toast to a 12-inch pizza, casseroles, roast dinners, and a variety of baked goods.
It comes with a unique roll-up door design to save space while also increasing visibility as well as access to the oven itself. This design is particularly handy for people wanting to place their oven on a shelf rather than just on a countertop.
Thanks to its convection technology that uses top and bottom heating elements and a built-in fan, your oven will cook all your favorite foods evenly.
Not only this, the manual buttons that come with it allow you to choose which cooking settings you’d like to use. These include baking, broiling, or toasting.
While slightly shorter than other models of its kind, the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Oven with Convection does come with a 30-minute timer so that you can sit back and relax while your toaster oven does all the work. Once the timer goes off, the toaster oven will turn itself off.
This Hamilton Beach model comes with a 9-inch by 11-inch bake pan included as well as a broil rack with two rack positions to choose from.
With its mound of features, you’ll benefit from easy access to all your favorite foods, thus allowing you to have a more convenient and positive cooking experience.
And, this is one of the only models that actually lets you choose between bake and convection giving you more creative freedom in the kitchen.
Last but not least, the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Oven with Convection comes in at a fraction of the price of other models on the market at just $47. By purchasing it on Amazon, you can buy an additional 2 or 4 years of protection for just over $1 and just over $3 respectively.
Before you can choose the best toaster oven for your kitchen, you need to consider your individual needs. While it may seem straightforward, toaster ovens now come in all shapes and sizes. Here are some consideration you should make before coming to a final decision:
Before you buy a toaster oven, think about what you are most likely to cook in it. If you want to toast some bread every morning then virtually any model will do, however, if you want to cook a roast dinner for the whole family, you may need to upgrade from your original choice.
Have you considered how much space you have on your kitchen counter to fit a toaster oven? As mentioned before, these come in all shapes and sizes, but you need to make sure that your chosen model doesn’t become a nuisance by taking up too much space in your kitchen.
Some of the best toaster ovens offer both audible and visual alerts. Having both will allow you to know when your food is ready.
This feature is especially handy for those that are less able to walk as you won’t have to get up and down from your chair to check on your meal, you can just wait for the alert.
Last but not least, choose a toaster oven that comes with a timer. Not only this, be sure that the timer is long enough to cook your preferred foods. Some models only come with 30-minute timers while others offer you 120 minutes before they turn off automatically.
Now that you know about some of the best toaster ovens on the market and are aware about some of the top considerations you need to think of before making your final buying decision, here are some key features available to choose from today:
The type of toaster oven you choose will completely depend on the meals you want to cook. Standard toaster ovens are great for making toast and cooking a pizza, for example.
On the other hand, if you want to do some baking or roasting, we recommend you check out the latest convection ovens on the market today. You can also choose combination ovens which allow you to bake, fry, and make a coffee all at once.
Lastly, there are also rotisserie toaster ovens which are perfect for roasting meats as well as infrared toaster ovens which send heat directly to the food rather than the area around it.
Typically, when choosing a toaster oven, you’ll be told what size pizza can fit in it and the number of pieces of toast it accommodates as well.
While you can look at the exact dimensions, these are great guidelines for establishing whether or not your chosen toaster oven is right for yours and your household’s needs.
Choose a toaster oven that has intuitive controls so that you don’t get confused while using it. While having lots of settings is great, these can be complicated to operate. Choose a model that comes with a variety of presets, some of which could be bake, toast, broil, among many others.
We all know how grueling it is to clean an oven. While a toaster oven is not quite as dirty or time-consuming it’s still not a very nice task. With this in mind, choose a model that you can wipe clean with a damp cloth after every use.
The best toaster ovens come with non-stick interiors which means that cleaning up even the toughest of messes is a breeze. You should also ensure that your toaster oven comes with a removable and easily accessible crumb tray to avoid any fire hazards.
In addition to all the above, you can opt for models that come with other unique additional features.
For example, some models come with a roll-up door rather than a door that opens sideways or downwards. These are especially useful if you want to save space in your kitchen and make it easier to take food out of your oven.
Not only this, some toaster ovens come with auto-reject racks which means that as soon as the door opens, the rack pulls out as well, giving you better access to your food.
Last but not least, make sure that your toaster oven comes with the right-sized accessories such as a bake pan. If it doesn’t make sure you can buy them for the right price.
Choosing the best toaster oven can be challenging. Aside from the mound of different types available today, you must also ensure that your chosen model meets your individual needs.
Not only this, always make sure that it comes with the right features so that you have the best cooking experience possible.
The products mentioned above are some of the best on the market and by choosing one of them you’ll be cooking amazing meals for you and your family to enjoy.